AbleNet not seeing both computers through a network switch

Hi, I’m running into a networking issue with my live rig and could use some advice on getting AbleNet to connect and sync my second machine across a network switch. I’m pretty novice at messing with any network stuff, so I’m going to try and be as detailed as possible.

Hardware & Network Setup:

*XR18: This is my in-ear and playback mixer for the main PC.

* Router: GL.iNet Opal router (housed inside a fly rack, assigns IP addresses to mobile devices to control their in-ear mix ).

* Main Computer: Runs the main Ableton Live session and AbleSet. Connected to the network switch.

* Visual Computer (Visuals/Redundancy): Runs an exact copy of the Ableton session with all audio removed. Connected to the network switch. Used mainly for keeping visuals off of my main laptop to help performance.

* Access Point: Used to extend the router’s wireless range. Connected to the network switch.

* Cudy Network Switch: Connects the Opal router, Main Computer, Visual Computer, XR18 and Access Point together.

The Problem:

Previously, I had both computers connected via the wireless access point, but I experienced occasional dropouts and stuttering. To make the connection more stable, I re-routed everything through a physical network switch.

While I can successfully ping both computers from each other using the command prompt, AbleNet only shows themself as one host.

At this point, I’m kind of at a standstill abusing Gemini to try to get me as far as I can. Any help would be appreciated.

  • OS and Version: Windows 11 Pro 10.0.26200
  • Version of AbleSet: 3.0.11
  • Version of Ableton: 12.4.2

Hey @Combo,

Thanks for the detailed description!

Here’s what I’d check, in this order:

1. Select the right network interface on both computers

If your computers still have WiFi enabled (from your previous setup) alongside the Ethernet connection, AbleSet might be using the wireless interface instead of the one connected to the switch.

On both computers, click AbleSet’s icon in the system tray, click the gear icon, and open Preferred Network. Make sure the Ethernet interface is selected there (each interface is listed with its IP address, so pick the one that matches the IP you’ve been pinging). If you don’t need WiFi on these machines, I’d turn it off completely.

You can see this in the official tutorial.

2. Connect the computers manually with Custom IPs

AbleNet uses Bonjour to find other AbleSet instances automatically. This works in most cases, but if it doesn’t, you can tell each computer where to find the other one:

  1. Open AbleSet’s Settings page and scroll down to the AbleNet section.
  2. On the main computer, enter the second computer’s IP address in the Connect to Custom IPs field.
  3. On the second computer, enter the main computer’s IP address.

Don’t enter a computer’s own IP there, only the other one’s. I’d also recommend giving both computers static IP addresses (or DHCP reservations in your Opal router) so you don’t have to update this field if the IPs change.

Here’s the relevant part of the tutorial.

3. Double check the following:

  • AbleNet is enabled on both computers (Settings → Redundancy & AbleNet).
  • Both computers run the same AbleSet version.
  • Both are loading the exact same Ableton set.

If you’re on Windows, it may also be worth checking that your Windows Firewall isn’t blocking AbleSet on the Ethernet network, especially if that network is set to “Public”.

A screenshot of the AbleNet section in the Settings on both machines would help as well.

If it still shows only one host after this, could you please create a Log Package on both computers?
You can create a log package by opening AbleSet’s icon tray, clicking the gear icon, and then selecting “Create Log Package”.
Please make sure to include your project files as well (just the .als files, no audio needed).
To send the files, you can upload them to AbleSet’s support inbox.

I’m looking forward to your reply!

Hey thanks for the quick reply!

After some trial and error, here is the workaround I found:

1. On my main computer, I set it up normally and open it. The “Connect to custom IP” box already has my visual PC’s IP address.

2. On my visual PC, I have to make sure that when I open AbleSet, I clear out the “Connect to custom IP” box.

3. Close AbleSet, reopen it, and while the box is still empty, resubmit my main PC’s IP.

4. Press enter then two host pop up.

Is there maybe some sort of log or some other information I can give to see why this happens, or is this maybe a standard procedure that I’m not aware of?

Edit: After removing some of those steps, it seems like all I have to do is resubmit my main PC’s IP on my second PC, which isn’t a huge deal. I didn’t know how automatic the process was.

Hey @Combo,

Glad you got both hosts to show up! And yes, each computer should have the other computer’s IP in the Connect to Custom IPs field.

AbleNet settings are stored per computer in your project’s Settings folder (in a specific-[hostname].json file), so once the IP is entered, AbleSet should reconnect on its own the next time you open it.

To narrow this down, could you check a couple of things?

  • Hostnames: Make sure both computers have different hostnames. Since the second computer runs a copy of the same project, duplicate hostnames could cause them to share the same settings file.
  • Preferred Network: On your visual PC, open AbleSet’s icon tray, click the gear icon, and check which interface is selected under Preferred Network. It should be the Ethernet interface connected to the switch.

If both look fine, could you please create a Log Package on your visual PC? Please create it right after opening AbleSet, before resubmitting the IP, so we can see what happens while it isn’t connecting.
You can create a log package by opening AbleSet’s icon tray, clicking the gear icon, and then selecting “Create Log Package”.
Please make sure to include your project files as well (just the .als files, no audio needed).
To send the files, you can upload them to AbleSet’s support inbox.

I’m looking forward to your reply!

Files sent! Funny enougth when I started them up today it was able to sync with no issue. Then after powering down and trying it again later is when it didnt work, thats when I made the log. Here is also a screenshot of after i resubmitted the main PC IP.

Hey @Combo,

Thanks for sending the logs and the screenshot!

We’ll go through the logs and get back to you as soon as we have a clearer idea of what’s going on.

Hey @Combo, I just went through your logs and I think I found the problem.

It seems that your laptop sometimes connects to a Wi-Fi network which uses the same (192.168.1.XXX) IP range as your Ethernet network. In that case, AbleSet tries to connect to the other computer via the Wi-Fi network which might not be possible.

I’ll see how I can make this more stable in the next version. In the meantime, the easiest workaround would be to turn off your laptop’s Wi-Fi. If you need to keep your Wi-Fi enabled, you can also change the IP address range of your Ethernet network, for example to (192.168.2.XXX) or (10.0.0.XXX).

Let me know if this helps, I’m looking forward to your reply! :slight_smile: